Is it cheaper to call a mechanic or a tow truck in Ireland?

A mobile mechanic can be cheaper for minor faults, but if the repair cannot be done roadside you may still need a tow, increasing the total cost.

How much does a tow truck cost in Ireland?

Short-distance towing in Ireland typically costs between €80 and €150, depending on location, time of day and vehicle type.

When should I choose towing instead of a mechanic?

Towing is usually the better option for engine, gearbox or electrical faults, or when a breakdown happens on a motorway where roadside repairs are unsafe.

Can calling a mechanic first increase my total cost?

Yes. If the mechanic cannot fix the issue onsite, you may pay for the call-out and still need a tow, effectively paying twice.

Mechanic vs. Tow Truck Costs in Ireland

When your car stops, the choice between a mobile mechanic and a tow truck depends on the problem, distance and budget. Both options have merits, and understanding the cost difference helps you decide quickly.

Mechanic vs tow truck: cost comparison

Option	Typical cost in Ireland	Best for	Main risk
Mobile mechanic	€70–€120 + parts	Minor faults (battery, belts, sensors)	You may still need a tow if repair fails
Tow truck	€80–€150 (short distance)	Serious faults, motorway breakdowns	Higher upfront cost

In Dublin, towing prices usually fall between €80 and €150, as explained in our guide on local towing costs. Mobile mechanics typically charge an hourly rate starting around €70, plus parts.

Case study

A driver in Limerick had a faulty starter motor. A mobile mechanic charged €90 for the call-out and advised a garage visit. The subsequent tow cost €100. Had the driver arranged a tow from the start, the total would have been lower.

Why you should know this

Understanding the trade-off prevents costly missteps and helps you choose the right service for your situation. Prices vary across counties, so getting quotes first is essential.

Practical tips

Describe symptoms clearly when phoning so the provider can recommend the best option.
Check if your insurance covers mobile repairs or towing.
Consider whether a quick fix is possible or if you need full breakdown recovery.

If the breakdown happens on a motorway, read what to do first on the M50 in Dublin before deciding.

When is a mechanic cheaper — and when is towing the better option?

A mobile mechanic is usually cheaper when the issue is clearly identifiable and can be fixed roadside within minutes. Examples include flat batteries, loose belts or simple sensor issues.

Towing becomes the better option when the fault involves the engine, gearbox, electronics or when the breakdown occurs on a motorway. In these cases, paying for a mechanic first can result in two charges: the call-out and the tow.

For more insights, explore our Q&A hub.

Need immediate assistance? Request a tow here